Jimmy Fallon & Nancy Juvonen

Unlike most Hollywood heartthrobs, Jimmy Fallon wins over girls through wits and humor. That’s not to say, though, that he’s not easy on the eyes. In fact, the Hollywood comedian and host has some stunning stars crushing on him, like Nicole Kidman and Kate Hudson.

However, of all the women that had a crush on him, nobody was quite as successful as Nancy Juvonen. They initially met on the set of Saturday Night Live when Fallon was still starting out but became closer when they started working on Fever Pitch. After dating for a while, he proposed to Juvonen in her family home in August 2007. The couple, however, had some troubles getting pregnant, so they opted to spend their investment money on surrogacy. Through the procedure, the couple welcomed their daughters Winnie Rose, born in 2013, and Frances Cole, born in 2014.